Electric vs. Gas Heaters

As winter draws near, the pressing question on everyone’s mind is how to keep the cold at bay. But when it comes to choosing between gas and electric heaters, the decision isn't always straightforward. Different households have different preferences, but which option is the best fit for you? We're here to break it down.

In this guide, we'll dive into everything you need to know about electric and gas heaters—from the crucial cost factors to environmental impact and beyond. By the end, you’ll be well-equipped to make an informed choice that keeps your home warm and your wallet happy.

Sound like a deal? Let’s dive in!

Let’s start with the burning question: which option is easier on the wallet—electric or gas heaters? There are a few factors to consider when budgeting for your new heater, including the upfront purchase price and ongoing running costs. Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered on both fronts.

Looking at initial costs, electric heaters tend to be more affordable up front. Fan heaters, for example, can start as low as £15, while higher-end models can go up to around £250. Within this price range, you’ll find a variety of heaters, including wall panel heaters, oil-filled radiators, stove heaters, and more.

Gas heaters also come in a wide range of prices. Portable gas heaters that use gas canisters average around £60, while gas wall heaters range from £150 to £1,200, plus around £150 for installation. If you’re considering a full gas central heating system, be prepared to invest between £3,500 and £7,000 for installation.

• Electricity = 24.5p/kWh
• Gas = 6.04p/kWh

Historically, gas heating has been cheaper to run, but the question is: are electric radiators cheaper than gas in the long term? To answer that question, it’s essential to factor in efficiency—while gas may be cheaper per unit, gas heaters often require more power to reach maximum efficiency. 

Ultimately, the running costs depend on energy and gas rates in your area and how you plan to use the heater.

Next up, let’s talk performance. How efficient are these heaters, and which one will best meet your needs? We’ve got some tips to help you make the most out of your choice. Case in point – stove fans; they’re an absolute must whether you have a gas or electric stove heater.  

Why?  

They’re self-powered and distribute heat around your space, with no extra running costs. With cost-savings like this, you can really maximise your heater’s performance. Head over to our stove fan guide to find out more. 

When choosing a heater, think about how you’ll use it. Do you need a portable option for quick warmth on cold evenings, or are you looking for something more permanent?

For a flexible, portable heating solution, electric heaters are the way to go. Since they’re powered by electricity, you can place them in any room with a plug socket. Most electric heaters also offer precise temperature control and timer functions, making it easy to create a cosy space.

Gas heaters, however, are less portable as they require a gas connection and typically need professional installation. If you’re looking for a long-term, steady heating solution, gas heating might be the better choice.

Electric heaters boast near-perfect efficiency, converting almost 100% of the electricity they use into heat. This high efficiency is a major plus when comparing electric radiators vs. gas options.

Gas heaters, on the other hand, typically operate at 70-90% efficiency due to energy loss during the heating process. However, efficiency isn’t the only factor—consider running costs, duration of use, and your specific heating needs.

You can read our blog on finding the most efficient heater right here.  

Today, we’re all more conscious of our environmental impact, and both gas and electric heaters have pros and cons when it comes to sustainability. Let’s explore how each option affects the environment and how you can make a greener choice.

Gas heaters rely on burning natural gas, which releases carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases—contributing to climate change. Additionally, extracting natural gas can lead to habitat destruction and water contamination, making gas heaters less eco-friendly.

Electric heaters, on the other hand, produce zero direct emissions. However, their environmental impact depends on the electricity source. If your electricity comes from renewable sources, electric heaters are a win for the planet. But if it’s powered by fossil fuels, the impact can still be significant.

Electric heaters take the lead in sustainability. Their combination of energy efficiency and reduced carbon footprint makes them a greener choice compared to gas heaters, which are becoming less sustainable as extraction costs rise. In short, electric heaters mean fewer emissions, less energy waste, and a more renewable future.

No matter which type of heater you choose, keeping it in good condition is key to staying warm and safe. Here’s what you need to do to maintain both gas and electric heaters.

Electric heaters are relatively low maintenance, requiring only basic checks for signs of wear, such as frayed cables or loose wires. As long as the vents are clear and everything looks good, you’re all set.

Gas heaters require more attention. Since they burn fuel, it’s crucial to have them serviced by a professional at least once a year. These annual services, which typically cost around £100, involve necessary checks and repairs to keep your heater running safely and efficiently.

Safety should always be a priority, no matter what type of heater you have. For electric heaters, always plug them directly into a wall outlet—not an extension cord—to avoid overheating. Keep them away from flammable materials like curtains or bedding, and never leave them running unattended.

For gas heaters, ensure you have a working carbon monoxide detector installed in your home. Adequate ventilation is also essential. And if you ever notice a strange smell, it’s better to be safe than sorry—call a professional to check it out. But don’t let these precautions scare you off – staying on top these simple checks will let enjoy the warmth without any worries.

Final Thoughts

Now that you’re armed with all the information, it’s time to make your choice. Whether you’re team gas or team electric, the key is finding a heater that meets your needs and keeps you warm all winter long.

By considering factors like cost, efficiency, and environmental impact, you’ll be well on your way to a cosy and comfortable home. So, take your pick, stay on top of maintenance, and enjoy the warmth—winter doesn’t stand a chance!